Front Range Pizza GuideColorado · Fort Collins to Pueblo

Live community results

Community leaderboard

Pizzerias are ranked using a weighted score, so a perfect score from one voter does not outrank strong results backed by many voters.

Unique voters
26
Total votes
113
How the scores are calculated

Weighted score = (ratings × shop average + 5 × category baseline) ÷ (ratings + 5).

The category baseline is the average of every submitted score in that category and acts like 5 neutral starting ratings. As a shop receives more ratings, its own average has more influence. At least 3 ratings are required for a rank; smaller samples appear in the provisional tables below.

Crust baseline
4.03
Sauce & cheese baseline
4.02
Overall baseline
3.96

Scores are calculated separately for each category and rounded to two decimal places. Equal scores share a rank.

Ranked shops

Crust

  1. #1 Postcard Pizza 4.55 Raw 4.88 · 8 ratings
  2. #2 Antonio's Real New York Pizza 4.32 Raw 4.50 · 8 ratings
  3. #3 Rosalee's Pizzeria 4.28 Raw 4.40 · 10 ratings
  4. #4 Rock City Pie and Ice 4.21 Raw 4.40 · 5 ratings
  5. #5 GFL Pizza 4.13 Raw 4.25 · 4 ratings
  6. #6 Abo's Pizza 4.10 Raw 4.17 · 6 ratings
  7. #7 Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage 4.09 Raw 4.14 · 7 ratings
  8. #8 Lina's Pizza (Granby) 4.02 Raw 4.00 · 3 ratings
  9. #8 Pizzeria Leopold 4.02 Raw 4.00 · 3 ratings
  10. #10 Main Stage Brewing 4.01 Raw 4.00 · 7 ratings
  11. #11 Slice House by Tony Gemignani 3.94 Raw 3.90 · 10 ratings
  12. #12 Sexy Pizza 3.83 Raw 3.67 · 6 ratings
  13. #13 Infinitus Pie 3.79 Raw 3.50 · 4 ratings
  14. #13 Pala Nero Pizza 3.79 Raw 3.50 · 4 ratings
  15. #15 Joy Hill Pizza 3.65 Raw 3.33 · 6 ratings
  16. #16 Simply Pizza Truck & Catering 3.64 Raw 3.00 · 3 ratings
  17. #17 Urban Field Pizza & Market 3.57 Raw 3.36 · 11 ratings

Sauce & cheese

  1. #1 Postcard Pizza 4.39 Raw 4.62 · 8 ratings
  2. #2 Abo's Pizza 4.28 Raw 4.50 · 6 ratings
  3. #3 Lina's Pizza (Granby) 4.26 Raw 4.67 · 3 ratings
  4. #4 Antonio's Real New York Pizza 4.16 Raw 4.25 · 8 ratings
  5. #5 Rosalee's Pizzeria 4.14 Raw 4.20 · 10 ratings
  6. #5 Slice House by Tony Gemignani 4.14 Raw 4.20 · 10 ratings
  7. #5 Pizzeria Leopold 4.14 Raw 4.33 · 3 ratings
  8. #8 Main Stage Brewing 4.09 Raw 4.14 · 7 ratings
  9. #9 Rock City Pie and Ice 4.01 Raw 4.00 · 5 ratings
  10. #9 GFL Pizza 4.01 Raw 4.00 · 4 ratings
  11. #11 Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage 3.92 Raw 3.86 · 7 ratings
  12. #12 Infinitus Pie 3.90 Raw 3.75 · 4 ratings
  13. #13 Sexy Pizza 3.83 Raw 3.67 · 6 ratings
  14. #14 Pala Nero Pizza 3.79 Raw 3.50 · 4 ratings
  15. #15 Simply Pizza Truck & Catering 3.76 Raw 3.33 · 3 ratings
  16. #16 Joy Hill Pizza 3.74 Raw 3.50 · 6 ratings
  17. #17 Urban Field Pizza & Market 3.44 Raw 3.18 · 11 ratings

Overall

  1. #1 Postcard Pizza 4.52 Raw 4.88 · 8 ratings
  2. #2 GFL Pizza 4.42 Raw 5.00 · 4 ratings
  3. #3 Antonio's Real New York Pizza 4.22 Raw 4.38 · 8 ratings
  4. #4 Abo's Pizza 4.17 Raw 4.33 · 6 ratings
  5. #5 Lina's Pizza (Granby) 4.10 Raw 4.33 · 3 ratings
  6. #6 Slice House by Tony Gemignani 4.05 Raw 4.10 · 10 ratings
  7. #7 Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage 3.99 Raw 4.00 · 7 ratings
  8. #8 Rock City Pie and Ice 3.98 Raw 4.00 · 5 ratings
  9. #8 Pizzeria Leopold 3.98 Raw 4.00 · 3 ratings
  10. #10 Rosalee's Pizzeria 3.92 Raw 3.90 · 10 ratings
  11. #11 Main Stage Brewing 3.82 Raw 3.71 · 7 ratings
  12. #12 Sexy Pizza 3.80 Raw 3.67 · 6 ratings
  13. #13 Infinitus Pie 3.76 Raw 3.50 · 4 ratings
  14. #13 Pala Nero Pizza 3.76 Raw 3.50 · 4 ratings
  15. #15 Simply Pizza Truck & Catering 3.73 Raw 3.33 · 3 ratings
  16. #16 Joy Hill Pizza 3.53 Raw 3.17 · 6 ratings
  17. #17 Urban Field Pizza & Market 3.36 Raw 3.09 · 11 ratings

Provisional shops

These shops have fewer than 3 ratings, so they are shown separately and do not receive a leaderboard rank yet.

Crust

Sauce & cheese

Overall